Not Yet in a Yom Kippur Mindset
by Jonathan Rosenblum
September 27, 2006
It is two days before Rosh Hashanah, and my assignment is to write a piece for the Yom Kippur issue. Having just returned from two weeks abroad, I am not yet securely enough in the Rosh Hashanah frame of mind to place myself in that of Yom Kippur.
The focus of the two poles of the teshuva process is very different. Rosh Hashanah bids us look forward. The blowing of the Shofar brings us back to the very first moment of human existence when Hashem blew the breath of life into Adam, and all human existence stretched in front of him. Yom Kippur, on the other hand, forces us to look backwards and scrutinize our deeds of the past year under a microscope.
There is no Al Cheit
on Rosh Hashanah, no confession of individual sins. Our first task is to crown Hashem as King over us. We do that by acknowledging that there is no existence apart from Him, and that true Life consists of attaching ourselves to the Source of all Life. That requires recognizing the Tzelem Elokim
within us, and our role as a "speaking being" (the Targum’s translation of "and Adam became a living being"). Each of us has some unique aspect of the Creator to reveal.
Ascertaining our specific mission requires contemplation of our particular strengths. Rabbi Yisrael Salanter used to say: It is sad if a person does not know his weaknesses, but far more tragic is the failure to recognize his strengths, for those strengths are the primary tools of his Divine service.
On Yom Kippur, however, we contemplate our failures not our strengths. On Yom Kippur we wash our dirty clothes, as it were, and purify ourselves from our sins. But that process can only begin when we first notice that our clothes are dirty and requiring laundering. That only happens when we develop a higher image of ourselves on Rosh Hashanah.
Surely, there is a lesson for all parents in the sequence. If we want our children to be able to deal with failure and accept criticism, we must first instill in them a sense of their own worth. Their basic self-conception must be a positive one, in which context their various failings are seen as unworthy diversions for one of their great merit.
IF I’M NOT YET READY to put myself in a Yom Kippur mindset, there is one event I associate with Yom Kippur that always bears contemplation. During the Yom Kippur War, Rabbi Chaim Shmulevitz, zt"l, the renowned Mirrer Rosh Yeshiva instructed bochurim
to confine their search for the four species to the barest minimum.
Reb Chaim stressed that at a time of imminent danger to Klal Yisrael
, the place of yeshiva bochurim
is in the beis medrash
. But beyond the protective power of Torah, Reb Chaim offered another reason for his edict. He asked the bochurim
to consider the feelings of a father or mother with a son on the front lines if they saw yeshiva bochurim
their son’s age peering through their magnifying glasses at lulavim
without a care in the world.
Reb Chaim’s acute sensitivity to the feelings of others is, unfortunately, a diminishing quality today. As our world grows ever larger and more self-contained, the awareness of those outside our world declines. And that trend is reinforced by our efforts to insulate ourselves and our children from the influences of an outside society whose values are often antithetical to those of the Torah.
We rightly teach our children to shut out the spiritually toxic environment around us and to wear blinders when they have to venture out of our protected neighborhoods. In addition, we teach them to be oblivious to what the outside world thinks of them and to carry themselves as proud Torah Jews – tzitzis
out and their dress showing no signs of aping secular fashions.
All this is not only understandable, it is vital to the protection of our precious neshamos. At the same time, we must not lose sight of the fact that this radical separation between different sectors of the Jewish people is far from ideal. And we must find ways to convey to our children that at some fundamental level they are connected to every Jew and bear responsibilities towards their fellow Jews.
Though we must not be deterred from our mitzvah observance by the ridicule directed at us by the secular world, we must still remember that ultimately it does matter what our secular brothers think of us because we bear a responsibility for bringing them to Torah and mitzvos.
The overwhelming response of chareidi chesed organizations to the needs of the refugees from the North during the more than month of fighting with Hizbullah shows that the spirit of Klal Yisrael
burns bright among many in the Torah world. They eagerly seize on those opportunities when we can put aside our differences and manifest an unadulterated ahavas Yisrael
. But we kid ourselves if we think that such concern for our fellow Jews is universal in our world.
As I pointed out last week, there are many reasons to believe in the wake of the failures of Lebanon that the hearts of our secular brethren are more open today to the message of Torah. The attitude of kochi v’otzem yadi
and belief in the invincibility of the IDF has been dealt a severe blow. There is a widespread recognition of the corruption and rot that follows from a self-centered pursuit of money and pleasure, and its destructive impact on every aspect of national life. And finally, Israeli Jews are searching for new sources of national will that will help us prevail against an enemy that is militarily weak but confident of the justness of its cause.
In order to bring others over to our point of view, however, we must first understand theirs. Without an effort to enter the mindset of another it is hard to convince him. Reb Chaim Shmulevitz provided a classic example of that ability to empathize with another’s situation.
May he be a model for us until that time when all Klal Yisrael
is purified before Hashem on Yom Kippur
Related Topics: Jewish Holidays, Rosh Hashana & Yom Kippur
receive the latest by email: subscribe to the free jewish media resources mailing list